When Warren Buffett bought PetroChina (PTR) in 2003, analysts dismissed it as a value trap in a corrupt state-run oil company. His 700% return in 4 years came from recognizing what the financials didn’t show — China’s coming energy dominance.
The Philosophy Behind the Bets
Buffett’s 2008 Goldman Sachs (GS) deal at the height of the financial crisis paid 10% annual dividends plus warrants. This wasn’t value investing — it was crisis capitalism with Berkshire’s (BRK.B) balance sheet as weapon. His framework:
- Only when the tide goes out (2008, 2020) can you see who’s swimming naked
- The best opportunities emerge where forced selling meets durable advantages
- Management quality matters more in turnarounds than stable businesses
Holdings That Prove the Pattern
| Ticker |
Entry Year |
Crisis Context |
Multiple Expansion |
Dividend Yield |
| BAC |
2011 |
Eurozone debt crisis |
3.2x |
2.4% → 3.8% |
| AAPL |
2016 |
iPhone slowdown fears |
4.1x |
0.6% → 1.8% |
| OXY |
2020 |
Oil price collapse |
2.7x |
0% → 4.2% |
| HPQ |
2022 |
PC market decline |
1.9x |
2.1% → 3.4% |
| CVX |
2020 |
ESG exodus |
2.3x |
5.1% → 6.3% |
The $4 Billion PetroChina Case Study
Buffett bought PTR at 0.8x book value when:
- Western investors feared China’s accounting standards
- Oil was $28/barrel (would peak at $147 in 2008)
- Political risk premiums ignored China’s infrastructure buildout
His exit in 2007 at 5.6x book value captured:
- 400% appreciation in oil prices
- China consuming 2x more energy than projected
- Valuation catching up to Exxon’s (XOM) multiples
What Buffett Would Do Today
Based on his 2026 shareholder letter, he’s:
- Still adding to OXY below $60 despite energy volatility
- Letting AAPL dividends compound (now 22% of Berkshire’s income)
- Avoiding tech disruptors — “I don’t pay for dreams that might not wake up”
Critics note his recent HPQ bet underperformed the Nasdaq by 18% annually. The counterargument? His 20% position in BAC has outperformed fintech disruptors by focusing on durable deposit franchises.
Ready to analyze these stocks? Search any ticker on MainRatios to see valuations from 6 legendary investors — free.
